Tag Archives: art criticism

RIP Peter Schjeldahl (1942 – 2022)

Peter Schjeldahl was een Amerikaans kunstcriticus die voor het eerst op mijn radar verscheen toen hij het carnografische El Topo (1970) van Jodorowsky in de zomer van 1971 een “monumentaal werk van filmkunst” noemde.

Bij ons las niemand Schjeldahl, afgezien van Joost Zwagerman die hem minstens drie keer in zijn essays vermeldde.

El Topo (1970), Spaans, Portugese ondertitels

Hier een cadeautje, de volledige versie van El Topo in het originele Spaans, met Portugese ondertitels.

RIP Peter Schjeldahl

RIP Roger ‘outsider art’ Cardinal (1940 – 2019)

Roger Cardinal was a English art scholar famous for originating the term “outsider art” in his book Outsider Art (1972). Outsider art coincides with the anti-psychiatry movement of the 1970s.

In that book, new to me was the work of Pascal-Désir Maisonneuve (1863 – 1934) who made work with seashells such as Mask of Queen Victoria (above), reminiscent of rocaille .

In that tradition is also Festoon, Masks and Rosettes Made of Shells (1656) by Jan van Kessel senior and Arcimboldesque Head and Beethoven Portrayed by Arcimboldo by Jan Švankmajer.

Eerie ears

Ears from Italian Painters

Ears from “Italian Painters”[1]


Clues, Myths, and the Historical Method by Carlo Ginzburg, a text famous for connecting Italian art critic Giovanni Morelli, British fictional character Sherlock Holmes and Austrian psychiatrist Sigmund Freud.

From that text:

“Morelli’s books look different from those of any other writer on art. They are sprinkled with illustrations of fingers and ears, careful records of the characteristic trifles by which an artist gives himself away, as a criminal might be spotted by a fingerprint . . . any art gallery studied by Morelli begins to resemble a rogues’ gallery . . .” (Wind 1963:40-41)